Partner with us

Why decarbonization has a market problem

Why climate pledges fall short of what is needed, why cutting carbon is hard for brands to justify, and what changes when buyers can see it.

4 min read

A woman looks through a rail of clothes in a shop.
Photo: Ron Lach on Pexels

45% versus 11–15%. The first number is how much global emissions need to fall by 2035. The second is what today’s climate pledges would deliver, according to UNEP.

Pledges and rules alone are not closing that gap. Part of the reason is money. For many brands, cutting carbon is still hard to justify as a business decision. Here is why, and what could change when buyers can see the carbon in what they buy.

How large is the gap between climate pledges and what is needed?

Large. Global emissions need to fall 45% by 2035, compared with 2025. The pledges countries have made so far add up to 11–15%. Both numbers come from the UN Environment Programme’s Emissions Gap Report 2026.

UNEP now assumes the world will pass 1.5°C of warming. The 45% is what it takes to keep the peak to about 1.7–1.8°C and have roughly an even chance of coming back to 1.5°C by 2100. The 11–15% assumes every country keeps its pledge in full.

To get there, emissions would have to fall by 5.7% a year, on average, from 2025 to 2035, UNEP estimates.

The gap is large. So is the room to close it. The same report shows renewable electricity capacity growing three times faster than was expected in 2015. It also finds that climate policies, where they have been properly evaluated, do cut emissions.

In our view, policy works and points the right way. On its own, it is not moving fast enough.

Why is the business case for decarbonization hard to make?

Because the money comes back slowly, if it comes back directly at all. In March 2026, H&M Group and EY published a paper on this with HSBC and the Apparel Impact Institute. It finds that most fashion brands know they need to invest in cleaner supply chains, but many have “difficulties making a business case” for it.

The paper explains why. Saving energy in a factory often pays for itself quickly. Bigger steps are different. Switching a factory from fossil fuels to renewable energy rarely pays off directly, or takes many years to. Factories also work for several brands at once, so a brand that pays to clean up a supplier lowers its competitors’ footprints too. And nobody knows what a tonne of avoided carbon will be worth in future.

The authors suggest ways through: tie emissions cuts to financial value inside the company, have brands share the cost of financing suppliers, and agree common standards and data. They also name another obstacle. Customers are not asking for it, and are unwilling to pay more.

That last obstacle is the one we work on. An investment is easier to justify when customers can see the result and choose it. Today they cannot: two shirts with different footprints look the same on the rail.

Are buyers ready to choose more sustainable products?

Many say they are. In 2025, Zalando surveyed 5,013 shoppers aged 18 to 44 in Germany, France, Italy, Sweden and the UK. Two in three (66%) described their fashion choices over the past year as very or fairly sustainable. And 71% said they would like to buy fashion more sustainably.

A word of caution. These are people describing themselves, not sales figures, and the questions were about sustainability in general, not carbon. What people say and what they buy are often different. Zalando’s report is about that gap, and how to close it.

So what stops them? Among the 4,755 who wanted to change, the most common answer was price: 41% said more sustainable fashion is too expensive. But 27% said it is hard to tell which items are more sustainable, and 19% said they do not trust what companies claim. (People could give more than one answer.)

Price is the biggest barrier, and better information will not make it go away. But the next two are about what buyers can see and believe. If you cannot tell two products apart, you cannot reward the company that cut its carbon.

What is demand-led decarbonization?

Demand-led decarbonization means buyers can see the carbon in a product, and their choices reward the companies cutting it. Lower-carbon products win sales, and those sales become a reason to cut further.

Rules push. Regulation and carbon pricing set a minimum, and subsidies make it cheaper to reach. Together they have driven real progress. But only demand can pull. It gives a company a reason to do more than the minimum.

Push Pull
What drives it Regulation, carbon pricing, subsidies Buyers’ choices
What a company gains Compliance and avoided cost Revenue
How fast it moves At the speed of policy At the speed of markets
What it depends on Enforcement Product carbon information buyers can see and compare

For pull to work, three things have to be true:

  • Visible. Buyers can see a product’s carbon at the moment they choose.
  • Trusted. The figure can be compared across similar products, and its reliability is stated.
  • Rewarded. A company that cuts carbon is recognised for it in buyers’ choices.

None of this replaces policy. It works alongside it. When progress pays, decarbonization stops being only a compliance cost and becomes a source of business value.

Fashion is not the only sector with this problem. In steel, cement and glass, the Cambridge Institute for Sustainability Leadership describes a catch-22: producers will not scale up low-carbon materials without demand, and buyers will not commit without a stable supply.

A note on the word “demand”. In energy policy, “demand-side” usually means using less energy, through efficiency and electrification. Here it means buyers choosing between products.

Karbonomics is building the economic system for demand-led decarbonization, starting with product carbon information people can use in everyday decisions. Read on: understanding a product’s carbon footprint.

Frequently asked questions

What is demand-led decarbonization?

It is decarbonization driven by buyers' choices as well as by rules. When buyers can see and compare the carbon in products, lower-carbon products win sales, and companies gain a commercial reason to keep cutting emissions.

Is demand-led decarbonization the same as demand-side energy measures?

No. Demand-side energy measures reduce how much energy is used, through efficiency and electrification. Demand-led decarbonization, as used here, is about buyers' choices between products rewarding the lower-carbon one.

How much do global emissions need to fall by 2035?

By 45% compared with 2025, according to UNEP's Emissions Gap Report 2026. That figure is for the pathway with the lowest remaining overshoot of 1.5°C. Current national pledges would deliver 11–15% if fully implemented.

What is the emissions gap?

It is the difference between the emissions expected under countries' climate pledges and the level consistent with a temperature goal. UNEP's 2026 Emissions Gap Report is the seventeenth edition.

Why do fashion brands struggle to make a business case for decarbonization?

Many of the larger investments pay back slowly, the benefit is shared with other brands using the same factories, and the value of avoided carbon is uncertain. These reasons are set out in a March 2026 paper by H&M Group and EY, with HSBC and the Apparel Impact Institute.

Do shoppers want more sustainable fashion?

Most younger European shoppers say so. In Zalando's 2025 survey of 5,013 people aged 18 to 44, 71% said they would like to buy fashion more sustainably. The answers are self-reported, and price was the most-cited barrier, at 41%.

Does demand-led decarbonization replace regulation?

No. Regulation and carbon pricing set minimum standards, and subsidies help companies meet them. Demand adds a reward for going further.

All stories